“Water with ice is obviously not a soup,” Lucas said, taking a bite of his sandwich. “Then it would be called ‘soup.’”
“Well, why not? The definition of soup is a liquid with chunks of something in it, and that’s what water with ice is,” Leo replied.
“Well, it says that it’s typically made of some sort of boiling meat or vegetables and there are no vegetables or meat in soup.”
“That doesn’t mean always,” Leo said. “‘Typically’ only means sometimes.”
“So, you’re saying that there is some soup out there that isn’t made with vegetables?”
` “Not exactly,” Leo said, taking a bite of his sandwich. “I’m just saying there could be. Which brings me back to my point that water with ice is soup.”
“I guess you have a point, but I still will never believe that water with ice is soup.”
“Well, maybe this will change your mind,” Leo said.
He then took a cup of ice water and poured it in a bowl. Then Leo put a cucumber in it, because there is such a thing as cucumber water.
“Wait a minuuutttteeee, that is soup! That is crazy, thank you for showing me that,” Lucas said.